ᴡ鷡

INCIDENT REPORT FEATURE: HATRA

U. S. DEPT. COOPERATION AGREEMENT NUMBER: S-IZ-100-17-CA021

BY Jamie O’Connell

An assessment of ISIS damage to Hatra

* This report is based on research conducted by the “Safeguarding the Heritage of the Near East Initiative,” funded by the US Department of State. Monthly reports reflect reporting from a variety of sources and may contain unverified material. As such, they should be treated as preliminary and subject to change.

The UNESCO World Heritage Site of Hatra (UNESCO)

The earliest excavated remains at the Parthian city of Hatra date to the mid-1st century CE, with most buildings constructed between 117 and 150 [1]. Despite thriving for less than two centuries until its capture and destruction by Sasanian forces in the 240s, the of Hatra are expansive. Hatra is first mentioned in historical sources in connection with an unsuccessful attempt by the Roman Emperor Trajan to capture the city, located on the Roman-Parthian border, in 116 [2]. Other sources for Hatra include the nearly 500 Aramaic inscriptions and graffiti discovered throughout the site.

An aerial photograph of the temenos of Hatra (Dr. Suzanne E. Bott, US State Department; October 16, 2009)

The remains of nearly 20 temples of various sizes have been identified within the large religious complex, or temenos, at the center of the city. These temples indicate Hatrene citizens worshipped a mixed pantheon with Mesopotamian, Iranian and Hellenistic elements [3].

Plan of the temenos of Hatra [4].

The main shrine in the central temenos is characterized by a series of large iwans (halls open to the front and roofed with high barrel vaults) to which a square temple dedicated to Shamash was attached.

A pre-damage view of the Great Iwans area, seen from the east (Col. M. Prophit; January 2010)
Collapse of a section of the eastern arcade, containing mosaic panels and other artifacts (TDA-HPI; June 16, 2015)

Smaller identified temples at the site include those dedicated to the goddess Allat and the god Miran. The correct dedications of several other temples (including the so-called Temple of the Triad and Temple of Shahru) are somewhat more controversial, as the temples often bear multiple dedicatory inscriptions to various deities [5].

Multiple excavations (largely concentrated on the central temenos) have been conducted at Hatra since the 1950s by Iraqi, Polish, and Italian teams [6]. The archaeological site was successfully to the UNESCO World Heritage List in 1985. It has been on the World Heritage in Danger List since 2015.

On February 27, 2015 the AFP that Hatra was at risk in light of looting and intentional destruction by ISIS militants at the Mosul Museum, where many artifacts excavated at Hatra were stored and displayed. On March 7, 2015 the Iraqi Ministry of Tourism and Antiquities a statement confirming that Hatra had indeed been attacked and captured by ISIS militants.

An ISIS militant destroys the statue of a Parthian king on display in the Mosul Museum.

In April 2015, ISIS a seven-minute-long video on Youtube (since removed) in which several militants are seen intentionally destroying various pieces of stone statuary and decorative architectural elements at Hatra.ISIS militants are shown using sledgehammers and pickaxes to destroy three of the carved stone faces adorning the entrances of the iwans, a statue in room 1 of the iwan, and an eagle carving on the south wall of room 12 of the Great Iwan.

A pre-damage photograph of a protruding carved head on right side of the entrance to room 13 of Great Iwans (Col. Mary Prophit; January 2010).
An ISIS militant uses a sledgehammer to destroy a carved head on right side of entrance to room 13 of the Great Iwans.
A pre-damage photograph of a carved relief of a face on the left side of the exterior doorway of room 4 of the Great Iwans (Col. M. Prophit; January 2010).
A video still of an ISIS militant using a sledgehammer to destroy the protruding head on the left side of the exterior doorway of room 4 of the Great Iwans.
A video still of an ISIS militant using a sledgehammer to destroy the carved face on, left side of exterior doorway of room 4 of Great Iwan.
A pre-damage photograph of a carved eagle on the south wall of room 12 of the Great Iwans (Col. M. Prophit; January 2010).
A video still showing an ISIS fighter using pickaxe to destroy the carved eagle on the south wall of room 12 of the Great Iwans.
A video still showing an ISIS fighter firing at the carved eagle on the south wall of room 12 of Great Iwans.
A pre-damage photograph of a statue now in room 1 of the Great Iwans
A video still of an ISIS militant using a pickaxe to damage a statue in room 1 of the Great Iwans.

Another militant is subsequently shown firing at the remains of the eagle, as well as several carved faces on the same wall.

A pre-damage photograph of reliefs of faces carved in the southwest corner of room 12 of the Great Iwans (Col. M. Prophit; January 2010).
A video still showing an ISIS fighter firing at carved reliefs on the south wall of room 12 of the Great Iwans.
A pre-damage photograph of the interior of room 12 of the Great Iwans (Dr. Suzanne E. Bott, US State Department; January 2010)

On April 26, 2017 forces from the Shia militia known as the Popular Mobilization Front (PMF) Hatra after launching an offensive on ISIS positions at Hatra and in the surrounding area early the previous day.

UNITAR conducted a damage assessment of a section of the site and noted smoke near the Temple of the Triad in a DigitalGlobe satellite image dated April 26, 2016.
A pre-damage photograph of the entrance to the Hellenistic (or Maran) Temple (Col. M. Prophit; January 2010)
A photograph of the colonnade of the Hellenistic Temple (from the southeast) showing damage from gunfire or mortars (Art Daily, April 27, 2017).
A pre-damage photograph of the south entrance of the so-called Temple of Shahru (Col. M. Prophit; January 2010).
A photograph of damage to the south entrance of the Temple of Shahru (Reuters; April 27, 2017).
A video still showing debris and a damaged wall in the interior of room 7 of the Great Iwans (Ruptly; April 29, 2017).

A photograph by Iraqi archaeologist Layla Salih shows evidence that ISIS used at least one area as a shooting range. According to Salih, ISIS used the site as a “military training center.”

A photograph showing a damaged statue in room 1 of Great Iwan, apparently used for target practice (Mosul Eye/Facebook; April 27, 2017).

In May 2017, the local head of antiquities in Iraq stated that most buildings at the site were intact. Photographs and video footage revealed that many statues at the site had been destroyed, buildings displayed fire damage, and mortars appear to have been stored in a courtyard at the site. The so-called Temple of the Triad was reportedly  into a car-bomb making factory.

A photograph of mortars lined up in front of the Temple of the Triad, reportedly used as an anti-aircraft position (Middle East Eye; May 6, 2017).

The bodies of dead ISIS militants were also at the site following its recapture. A PMF commander that an “exterior wall was damaged, shots fired by Daesh [ISIS] left holes in some buildings, two grand halls of the ancient palace suffered fires, and shrapnel from shells affected the western part.” It was also reported that the eastern section of the site had been to deter PMF advances, preventing closer damage inspections.

A pre-damage photograph of the Temple of the Triad (Wikipedia Commons; May 3, 2006).
A video still showing fire damage to the Temple of the Triad (top right) (Ruptly; April 29, 2017).
A video still of a detonated car in the interior of the western room of the Temple of the Triad (Ruptly; April 29, 2017).
A photograph of a PMF fighter examining a large whole in room 13 of the Great Iwans, reportedly created to allow ISIS militants to move through the structure unseen (Middle East Eye; May 6, 2017).
A pre-damage photograph of the eastern wall of the Hatra temenos (Dr. Suzanne E. Bott, US State Department; October 16, 2009)
A photograph shows the partial collapse of gateway and wall section on the eastern edge of the temenos area (Rudaw; April 27, 2017)

In December 2017, more photographs showing the current state of Hatra were published. These images show statuary and building facades that appear to have been intentionally damaged by gunfire. Some photos also show damage due to weathering and neglect of the site. In particular, a large statue located on the western side of the so-called Temple of Shahru was completely destroyed, along with columns in a nearby colonnade.

A pre-damage photograph of a statue located on the western side of the Temple of Shahru (Dr. Suzanne E. Bott, US State Department; October 16, 2009).
A photograph shows the destruction of a statue the western side of the Temple of Shahru, as well as shrapnel holes in nearby walls and columns (ASOR CHI Source; December 14, 2017).
A photograph shows shrapnel holes and the destruction of columns on the western exterior side of the Temple of Shahru (ASOR CHI Source; December 14, 2017).

For more information on damage to Hatra, see ASOR CHI Incident Report IHI 15-0068 in ; IHI 15-0068 UPDATE in ; IHI 17-0024 int; IHI 17-0024 UPDATE in ; and IHI 17-0085 in .

Sources:

[1] L. Dirven, ed. (2013) Hatra. Politics, Culture and Religion between Parthia and Rome. Oriens et Occidens – Band 21. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner Verlag. 14.

[2] B. Dignas & E. Winter (2012) Rome and Persian in Late Antiquity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 20.

[3] L. Dirven (2014) “Religious Continuity and Change in Parthian Mesopotamia,” Journal of Ancient Near Eastern History 1(2): 19; T. Kaizer (2000) “Some remarks about the religious life of Hatra,” Topoi 10: 229.

[4] Kaizer 2000: 252.

[5] Dirven 2013: 16.

[6] Ibid. 10, 14.